Salone News

A Plan to Alleviate Poverty in Sierra Leone

9 December 2007 at 04:13 | 7627 views

On November 7, 2007, the SALONEDiscussion Think Tank Committee authorized the delivery of a compendium of recommendations to President Ernest Koroma. The recommendations addressed ways to restore the value of the Leone, and electricity, water and sanitation services to SL. This newspaper will be serializing the four chapters of the compendium. Today, we publish the first chapter of the compendium dealing with the restoration of the value of the Leone.

By Mohamed A. Jalloh, Jonathan Rose, Julius Aruna, Archimedes Faulkner and Mahmud Mansaray (USA).

Highlights of Plan

Goal: To immediately reduce the cost of living in Sierra Leone (SL), and thereby reduce poverty among millions of Sierra Leoneans, by arresting and reversing the 30-year long catastrophic decline in the exchange rate of the Leone which is the major source of unprecedented inflation and other distortions in the economy of Sierra Leone.

Key to Success: Provision of sufficient foreign exchange within the official banking system to meet the legitimate demand of Sierra Leoneans at an exchange rate progressively equal — or close — to that of the Leone to the U.S. dollar in 1979 prior to its devaluation that year.

Actions Needed:

1. Set a goal to bring down the current exchange rate of the Leone to the U.S. dollar by twenty-five percent (Le 2,250 = $1) by December 31, 2008, by fifty percent (Le 1,500 = $1) by December 31, 2009, by seventy-five percent (Le 750 = $1) by December 31, 2010, and to parity (Le 1 = $1) at the end of 2011.

2. Bring all foreign exchange transactions in SL within the official banking system by strictly enforcing laws against smuggling and other evasions of foreign exchange control regulations, including the operation of money transfer/exchange bureau businesses outside the Bank of Sierra Leone’s oversight.

3. Defer a decision to join a single West African currency until the successful completion of the effort to restore the value of the Leone.

4. Launch an effective public education campaign to inform Sierra Leoneans about the direct connection between parallel market activities and the high cost of living for Sierra Leoneans.

5. Install security measures to safeguard the integrity of the Leone, including anti-counterfeiting measures.

Sources of Foreign Exchange to Finance Restoration of the Value of the Leone: Remittances from Diaspora Sierra Leoneans, foreign aid in the form of grants and/or low-interest loans, loans to the SL government from Diaspora Sierra Leonean organizations, direct investment by Sierra Leoneans abroad in the local economy, and increased official foreign exchange receipts resulting from a significant reduction in smuggling and parallel market transactions.

1.The Fundamental Problem Obstructing Development in SL

The perennial ranking of Sierra Leone among the five poorest countries in the world despite the country’s abundant natural resources and its receipt of more than $2 billion in foreign aid since independence attests to the failure of past efforts to develop SL’s economy. Clearly, it is time for a new approach to solving SL’s economic problems.

Those problems, which have long retarded SL’s development, can be segregated into three broad categories - infrastructural deficits ( e.g., inadequate electricity, water, roads, sanitation, medical and educational services), poor governance (e.g., corruption and a dysfunctional judiciary), and poor economics (e.g., inadequate production of food and other essential items, excessive dependence on imported goods and services, inadequate personal incomes, and a resultant untenably high cost of living). Among these myriad national problems, four have been identified as warranting the immediate attention of the new government because they are perceived to pose the greatest danger to the development of our country - the lack of electricity, water and sanitation and the high cost of living. The problems associated with electricity, water and sanitation are addressed in separate sections of this compendium. The focus of this section is alleviating the excessively high cost of living in SL.

Why should the SL government focus on the resolving the high cost of living facing millions of Sierra Leoneans as a major solution to SL’s economic problems? The answer is that the cost of living, which is usually measured by a price index such as the consumer price index (CPI), by definition, is the average cost of the basic necessities of life such as food, shelter, clothing, transportation, utilities etc. Accordingly, it represents the truest measure of the impact on the income of the average Sierra Leonean of the sum total of all economic activity affecting SL. Therefore, the goal of alleviating poverty directly translates into the goal of reducing the cost of living at a given level of average income. To put it another way, the goal of reducing poverty translates into the goal of increasing the purchasing power of the average Sierra Leonean to the level sufficient to sustain a standard of living above the poverty level.

The question, then, is how can this be done? In order to answer that question, it is necessary to answer an intermediate question, namely: What is the impact of the current very high cost of living on the development of SL?

2.The Impact of the High Cost of Living on the Development of SL.

It is no exaggeration to state that the very high cost of living facing Sierra Leoneans almost entirely explains the arrested development and retrogression of SL’s economy. However, the cost of living is not itself an independent variable affecting the SL economy. It is useful mainly as a single measure of the impact on the purchasing power of the average Sierra Leonean of the basic factors that affect the economy - production, demand and inflation. Thus, the search for the root cause of the high cost of living must start with an examination of production, demand and inflation in SL.

Most economists regard the economy of Sierra Leone as still primarily agricultural. However, there is a growing number of researchers who now believe that the country has a mixed economy consisting of agriculture and mining. While the output of the mining sector has progressively increased, especially after the recent war, a similar result is lacking in the agricultural sector. Yet, it is the agricultural sector that provides about half of the basic necessities of life for the people in the country. So, it is primarily the lack of basic food items and their resultant high cost that has helped to fuel the current high cost of living in the majority of the cities in Sierra Leone. In addition, over-population in some of the large cities, especially Freetown, has helped to fuel an increased pressure for space, particularly rental properties. As a result, rents are now so astronomical that they can hardly be afforded by the average Sierra Leonean.

The predictable result of these production shortages in the face of increasing demand from a rising and increasingly urban population has been massive and pervasive inflation in SL. Figures from the Bank of SL, using 2003 as a base year, confirm this trend. The CPI for the country rose from 111.02 in 2004 to 132.53 in 2005. It escalated to 144.19 in 2006, and by the end of August 2007, it had risen to 163.91.

A similar trend was observed for SL’s four major cities. The CPI for Freetown rose from 114.9 in 2004 to 131.8 in 2005, only to increase to 142.4 in 2006. By the end of August 2007, it had risen to 158.08. The trend in Bo was similar. The CPI increased from 116.5 in 2004 to 124.2 in 2005 and escalated to 133.4 in 2006, only to increase further to 155.40 at the end of August 2007. The CPI for Kenema exhibited a familiar pattern, rising from 116.0 in 2004 to 127.2 in 2005, only to escalate to 135.9 in 2006. By the end of August 2007, it had risen to 155.2. The CPI for Makeni, similarly to that for Kenema, rose from 117.6 in 2004 to 127.7 in 2005. It then increased to 135.8 in 2006. At the end of August 2007, it had escalated to 156.1.

In the case of individual items in Freetown, a similar escalating trend was manifest. For instance, using 1992 as base year, the CPI for food rose from 364.63 in August 2004 to 414.69 in August 2005. It then jumped to 430.53 in August 2006 before escalating to 477.51 in August 2007.

One of the most lethal economic consequence of low production in the face of rising demand and ensuing inflation in our country has been the generation of a vicious cycle of poverty - the more essential items continue to be scarce, the more their prices continue to rise, the greater the inflation rate, the more the government resorts to deficit financing and the greater is the impact of the vicious cycle of poverty. Eventually, the government resorts to using its limited foreign exchange earnings derived from the mining sectors to subsidize the agricultural sector by importing food items and other essential items which would otherwise have been grown locally. This leads to greater budget deficits, trade imbalances and hyperinflation as the vicious cycle is fueled anew.

We believe, based on the above historical analysis that the single greatest contributor to SL’s economic crisis is the same one as that identified by one of the greatest economists of the 20th century, Lord John Maynard Keynes of Great Britain. In his seminal 1919 treatise, "The Economic Consequences of the Peace," Lord Keynes accurately predicted that the destruction of the value of the German currency would precipitate a second world war, because, as he put it: " There is no subtler, no surer means of overturning the existing basis of society than to debauch the currency. The process engages all the hidden forces of economic law on the side of destruction, and does it in a manner which not one man in a million is able to diagnose. "

For largely similar reasons, we believe SL’s economic crisis to be rooted in the debauchery of the country’s currency. Accordingly, we propose a never-before-tried measure in SL — the restoration of the value of Sierra Leone’s currency — as the cornerstone of an economic recovery program for our country. This proposal is aimed at reversing the unprecedented inflation and other distortions in SL’s economy in the wake of the 1979 devaluation and subsequent depreciation of the Leone that have made it virtually impossible to sustain economic growth or alleviate poverty.

Whereas devaluation is a potent cure for balance of trade problems in industrialized countries, in Sierra Leone it has spawned perverse consequences. In particular, devaluation has induced a condition of fundamental disequilibrium by creating a self-perpetuating vicious cycle of poverty - low incomes leading to low demand that leads to low production which leads to lower incomes.

Infrastructure has been depleted and the ability to maintain viability as a sovereign nation has rapidly decreased. The interruption of this cycle requires either massive external intervention, in general, or a controlled reversal of the currency devaluation, in particular.

3.Recommended Solution to the Problem of Poverty in SL

Our proposal to restore the value of the Leone is specifically intended to break that vicious cycle of poverty in which millions of Sierra Leoneans have long been trapped by reversing the deterioration of the value of the currency.

How to Implement a Restoration of the Value of the Leone.

The restoration of the value of the Leone requires meticulous and diligent planning for it to succeed. At a minimum, the process should be transparent and equitable enough to afford each and every Sierra Leonean a reasonable opportunity to adjust their business, educational, social and/or bureaucratic activities to the expected realities prescribed by the intended new exchange rate.

It can be done by a SL government decree to re-establish a par value for the currency against a major world currency such as the US dollar or the British pound. While government intervention is critical, simply decreeing the par value of the currency is not sufficient. Issues such as the use of old currency and corruption of the restoration process could derail the effort. It also could potentially create a greatly destabilizing situation.

Alternatively, value in the Leone can be re-established through open market interventions, including, but not limited to, actions by the Sierra Leone government and private Sierra Leoneans pursuing their legitimate business and other interests, in buying and selling foreign currency. While this would require far more time than a decree, it would inspire greater market confidence, create lesser disturbance of social strata, and distribute the wealth being injected into the country more evenly than by simple government fiat.

We recommend that the SL government set a goal to bring down the current exchange rate of the Leone to the U.S. dollar by twenty-five percent (Le 2, 250 = $1) by December 31, 2008, by fifty percent (Le 1, 500 = $1) by December 31, 2009, by seventy-five percent (Le 750 = $1) by December 31, 2010 and at par (Le 1 = $1) at the end of 2011.

4.Financing the Restoration of the Value of the Leone.

Whichever mechanism is chosen, the infusion of foreign exchange into the banking system at levels sufficient to sustain the exchange rate of the Leone at the targeted rates of exchange with the benchmark foreign currency will be critical to the success of the restoration of the value of the Leone. This is where foreign aid can play a critical role — by providing the foreign exchange required to sustain the exchange rate through the transition period until market stability is achieved without the need for such support.

Other sources of foreign exchange needed to finance the restoration of the value of the Leone are increased official foreign exchange receipts resulting from a significant reduction in smuggling and parallel market transactions, remittances from Diaspora Sierra Leoneans, loans to the SL government from Diaspora Sierra Leonean organizations, and direct investment by Sierra Leoneans abroad in the local economy.

The benefits of restoring the value of the Leone will be significant: The harmful parallel market for foreign currency would disappear, thereby restoring all foreign exchange transactions within the official banking system. This will decrease the need for foreign exchange support by aid donors. The removal of the distortions in SL’s economy would engender growth by removing the purchasing power disadvantage imposed upon indigenous Sierra Leoneans which has acted as a powerful restraint against efforts by Sierra Leoneans to launch successful local businesses. The government would benefit from a resultant increase in income tax, customs duty and other revenues generated by expanding economic activities.

At that point, the remaining focus of efforts to alleviate poverty would be SL government action to correct income disparities that would otherwise prevent the widespread dispersal of the benefits of the economic growth resulting from the restoration of the value of the currency.

© 2007 SALONEDiscussion

Photo: Mohamed Jalloh, one of the contributors to the compendium.

Comments